Reviews The Eatalian

Facebook
Cindy Bonelle
+5
Orgasmic food, fantasy ambiance and superb service. The owner is absolutely charming and gives the whole experience a personal touch!
Facebook
Tristan Spiess
+5
Wonderful little gem. Just off the main road, has a wonderful atmosphere, friendly staff all round and a great kitchen. The various "Chef Specials" are always a treat. They make you feel welcome here.
Facebook
Sheilagh O'Gorman Cheketri
+5
One of my favourite restaurants. Always have good food, wine + service. I'll be back again + again + again.......
Facebook
Nicole Megan Daniels
+5
This is probably the best restaurant I've been to in Johannesburg!! The service was absolutely excellent! The food was perfect ♡
Facebook
Sindy Kotze
+5
First time and loved this place! Ambiance, Food and Service - Excellent.
Facebook
Thabo Motlhathudi
+5
Stunning food with a great atmosphere and excellent service
Facebook
Bev Meyerowitz Bricker
+5
Excellent food... coffee great!!! Good service... great � ambiance
Facebook
Christo De Jager
+5
Superb...! Food was fantastic, service great...! Stumbled across the restaurant by accident, but had a superb dinner. Will most certainly be back for more...!
Facebook
Nicola Quagliere
+5
The best italian restaurant i tried in Southafrica.
Facebook
Lee Egling
+5
Ambience was awesome and pasta that I had was delicious
Zomato
Tshepang Tee
+5
Went there for lunch with colleagues and the food was amazing, tasty, fresh, just overall fantastic!
Service was great.
Had an amazing time there!
Jun 14, 2019
Zomato
Christy Lee Edmunds
+4
The linguine pollo is extremely tasty. It’s my husbands favorite pasta. The service is good and so are the pizzas. Never had a bad meal here. Really nice for a Sunday lunch
Apr 07, 2019
Zomato
Humaira
+5
An absolutely amazing place to enjoy, fresh, homemade Italian cooking. The servers are wonderful and tend to your every need, and accompanied by the chic yet homely atmosphere, The Eatalian is truly the place to be.

For starters I indulged in a garlic, herb and cheese focaccia which was absolutely mouth watering. The thin, crispy crust and the flavorsome topping made every bite even more tantalizing that the last.

For mains I had the Farfalle al Filetto, a classic creamy Napoletana sauce, with succulent steak and texturing mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes, as well as classic farfalle pasta. With every mouthful I was drawn back for more as the rich, creamy nature of the sauce accompanied by the succulent fillet and flavorsome accompaniments left a wonderful taste residing in your mouth.

Ultimately I had a wonderful experience and I’d definitely come back again and again as this has become a family favorite, definitely a recommendation to others willing to try it as well!
Feb 14, 2019
Zomato
Zomato Reviewer
+4
Loved the Mac and Cheese the focaccia with cheese. Pulled lamb and Cajun chicken pizzas where also great. Will def visit again to try the rest of the menu
Jan 26, 2019
Zomato
LKKotze
+4
What a lovely and relaxed atmosphere and such good service to accompany it. Make us feel at home from the very start and even did some custom cocktails for us. Then the food, where we also ordered some items not on the menu, easily accommodated. The only regret I have is not taking a picture to show you guys the best gnocchi quattro formaggi that I've had in my life...

Big thumbs up and a must
Nov 25, 2018
Zomato
Leone Boshoff
+5
Delicious and authentic Italian food! Good service and good ambiance. Everything we’ve ordered from their menu has been a success, especially their pizzas and desserts.
Sep 02, 2018
Zomato
Gladwin
+5
My wife and I took some friends out to dinner, boy were we delightfully surprised. Fabio and the staff treated us excellently. The food was rich and surely made with love. Atmosphere is warm and cozy with music playing subtly in the background. This is a top Italian eatery that must be tried out. Thank you Fabio, we loved the experience.
Aug 21, 2018
Zomato
G Makan
+4
Beautiful Italian food prepared with love and care! The use of truffle is perfect in certain dishes. Fresh flavors and exciting variety. Will definitely be back...
Jul 03, 2018
Zomato
Nevolan Reddy
+5
So yesterday my wife and i decided to visit The Eatalian, after being referred there by Deepin Sukha. We were greeted warmly by a number of waiters before we even got into the restaurant. This was a huge plus as normally only the waiter that is assigned to the table you sit at would greet you.

We were then told to choose any table and take a seat, it was rather quiet. We chose a table close to the oven and then took a look at the menu. We sort of already knew what we wanted to eat so we took a look at the drinks. I ordered an Iced Coffee and @Prenisha Reddy had a cappuccino. Our meal choice was Messicana without the beef bolognaise, and extra pulled lamb instead.

Lets start with the drinks: The cappuccino was strong. Really strong. But good nonetheless. We had to get some extra milk to dilute it a bit, but it certainly was made with some good quality beans. As for the Ice Coffee, it was really really good. I went for the ice cream option as opposed to the traditional ice version. It was really tasty and quite difficult to finish.

Now on to the pizza, the undeniable star of the show. A thin crust with cheesy deliciousness, some green peppers and cooked onion rounded off with the best tasting pull lamb in Johannesburg. The pizza was really that damn good. Could have had a bit more chilli, being a "Mexican" pizza in hiding, but thats what the chilli on the table is for right? The chilli on the table really elevates the pizza.

I really enjoyed the food and the company was great as usual. Would definitely recommend this place to any pizza fundi. Absolutely amazing. And the service from Freedom, our waiter was also quite good. Wonder why it was so quiet though???

Note to Management: Please consider offering a Lamb/Chicken version of your Messicana and a bit more chilli prior to baking the pizza in the oven.
Mar 29, 2018
Zomato
Catia Madalena
+4.5
After being to Italy, and having an Italian boyfriend who's mother has blown my mind with almost every meal she cooks, Italian restaurants are rarely a hit with me anymore. What can I say? I'm ruined. However, this place continuously makes me beyond happy! Their Italian sausage pizza and their arancini balls are my favourite go-to's! I'm not a fan of seafood pasta, but many have raved about that too. The owner is a hardcore traditional Italian man who studied in Rome and I love the authenticity that this little spot in Parkmore holds. It is pricey, but all authentic ingredients are imported. All in all, it's certainly cheaper than visiting Rome...
Mar 27, 2018
Zomato
Robyn Woods
+5
Good food, amazing service and best Limoncello in town.
We come here often and have never been disappointed. A family friendly spot but also great for a quiet date night.
The owner is present and friendly.
A good option always.
Mar 22, 2018
Zomato
Mbali Sibongile Tshabalala
+5
Authentic Italian at its best.👌🏽This place serves the best pizza and pasta in town!!! The pollo pizza is my favorite, the base is nice and thin, the toppings are fresh and tasty. The decor and ambiance is great for any occasion, the staff and owners are very friendly.
Jan 23, 2018
Zomato
Sabrina Beale
+5
Food is amazing, wait staff are friendly, vibe is great, I love this restaurant! Prices to make you cringe a little but the food does not disappoint.
Oct 02, 2017
Zomato
Jojobarrow
+5
We live down the road and love popping into this local Italian eatery. The vodka pasta is a DREAM and I come back for it every time! Pizzas are thin and crispy and delicious. We always get greeted warmly and service has been great. Haven't tried much else on the menu because I always have the same thing but there's a huge selection of authentic Italian and something for everyone! Highly recommend!
Sep 10, 2017
Zomato
Anna Banana 🌻
+3.5
The time between ordering and bringing the food was too long but when it did come: excellent quality. Lovely environment and their Pizza is their biggest strength!
Aug 23, 2017
Zomato
Foodie Reviewer
+4
Always friendly service, and the food is good Italian fare, but a tad pricey. Beautiful restaurant and I love the fact that it is adding to the 11th street Parkmore sidewalk atmosphere. I would suggest sit in rather than take aways - their pizzas are best served straight out of the oven! My husband loves the one with the mushrooms and truffle oil, I tend to make my own.
Aug 15, 2017
Zomato
Yajna
+4
Went to Eatalian during the week with a large group of colleagues. Everyone was satisfied and happy with their meals. The pastas were great, we had a variety of seafood pasta, calamari and mushroom pasta and prawn risotto. Another colleague tried the lamb chops and really enjoyed it and I had the salmon, medium done. Really enjoyed everything on the table! For dessert we tried the Nutella tiramisu and the dark chocolate mousse, both were lovely but the tiramisu is definitely worth a try. Quaint, arty little spot - small gem on the corner of the street. Service could be a bit better but it's hardly bad enough to cause a scene over. I'd go back.
Jul 31, 2017
Zomato
Kirsten
+4.5
We were a table of 6, and everyone thought their food was wonderful - pastas, pizzas and foccacias. All good value for money, great fresh ingredients and good portion sizes. The Nutella tiramisu was heaven on a plate. The wine list was quite pricey, but offered a decent selection. The decor and vibe were great, and service was above average despite being a packed Saturday night.
Jul 20, 2017
Zomato
G
+5
Brilliant food - shocking background music.

Probably the best Pizza and Pasta in JHB. Great looking place , quaint and casual. Prices are correct for the Excilient food.

Hard to find better but the background music is soft rap SHOCKING as manager to play Italian music rather..
May 22, 2017
Zomato
Misskatewells92
+5
Delicious food, beautiful decor and a good vibe. The waiter was friendly and looked after us all evening. What a lovely experience. Will definitely go back.
Mar 21, 2017
Zomato
Linda
+3.5
Decided to try this restaurant for some afternoon dessert. The decor inside this restaurant is beautiful. The menu oozes Italian deliciousness and the desserts are amazing. However, the servers aren't the friendliest and despite asking for single shot coffee we got double shots and it was so strong we couldn't drink it. Look forward to trying their pizzas !
Mar 19, 2017
Zomato
Carli Gaddin
+5
What a hidden treasure in the heart of Parkmore... have visited Eatalian on several occasions and have enjoyed every single meal! The waiters are great and so knowledgeable on the menu and ingredients! Spent my 31st birthday there with my boyfriend and it's a definite go to for anything Italian!
Mar 04, 2017
Zomato
Nadia Myburgh
+3.5
I love this place.  I have come here a few times, always leaving satisfied.  The ambiance,  staff and pizzas are always amazing.  
Last night however, I was slightly disappointed with the Farfalle Al Filetto.  The entire dish was so unseasoned and bland that it had to be loaded with parmesan and chili and then some.  The meat did not taste like Filet at all and left a turning taste.  
I'll always come back though, and the Gorgonzola Focaccia and good waiter made up for it.
Feb 24, 2017
Zomato
Nerina...
+3.5
I pass this place ever day and it's always busy, decided to try the breakfast which turned out to be great and then again for a few time for dinner. It does get busy and you probably should book... Fairly kiddy friendly during the non peak periods but not so much when it's crowded. Overall I really enjoyed the food and atmosphere ... Good pasta and pizza - could tell it was made fresh and was authentic.
Will stop by again but will have to choose my time well if I intend bring the kids again.
Feb 05, 2017
Zomato
Amy Sophia Esterhuizen
+3.5
If you are looking for good pizza with interesting toppings in the area this is the place to go! Some of the pastas are also delicious too, would recommend the Linguine Pollo. The service is good and the atmosphere great.
Nov 19, 2016
Zomato
Renzo Sartori
+3.5
The vibe was great the service good,typical Italian food that could do with a little more passion.
Will be back to try other dishes on the menu.
Oct 10, 2016
Zomato
The Pretoria Explorer
+4.5
Okay guys I'm going to tell you a nice story.. I love zomato because of this. So I was on my way to a meeting to Sandton and my director asked me if we could stop for lunch. It was recommended on zomato and the rating was good. The restaurant is in a nice spot and is quite informal with a good atmosphere. The amount of business meetings that were taking place were shocking in the restaurant. The food was so so so good and the presentation on point. I ate this pizza with meatballs on it and with Tabasco it blew me away. The best part of the day was the freshly ground coffee which the owner himself roasts upstairs.. the setting made me feel like I was at home 🏡
Sep 25, 2016
Zomato
Daniel
+3.5
We went on a Sunday afternoon. There was nothing great about the Quattro pizza. Meals were plain and somewhat overpriced. Underwhelming at best
Sep 17, 2016
Zomato
Sharima Bramannan
+4
This was such a lovely dining experience. Obviously very popular cos even at 17:30 it was quite busy. We had the focaccia to start...had generous amounts of cheese. For mains I had the chicken schnitzel with Gorgonzola & peppadew sauce...luv'd this. Then I had the Nutella tiramisu for dessert...it was nice...I wish the Nutella taste was stronger than the alcohol taste. All in all a lovely experience...nice vibe, excellent service!
Sep 16, 2016
Zomato
ROBERT ELLIS
+4
I had a very enjoyable dining my experience at this romantic spot. A very trendy and warm/cosy feel, with great service and a great meal. We ordered the antipasto misto for 2, and it was great. A very tasty filling portion of mixed cold meats, artichoke, buffalo mozzarella ect.

And then I ordered the Pollo Linguine and it was to die for. A massive portion with a creamy garlic sauce, tender pieces of chicken and sundried tomatoes which all combined superbly. Really enjoyed my meal and experience
Aug 31, 2016
Zomato
Crumbs
+5
I dream about their Paesanna Pizza, all mushroom & sausage & cheese, try swap sausage for Parma ham, always with a drizzle of truffle oil. Heaven.
Might be letting out a little secret... Real truffles, just might be available for a pasta delight...For a few days. & yes; service is always just right b
Aug 14, 2016
Zomato
Ryan Bradbury
+5
I am in Jhb on business and decided to pop into this Italian restaurant... I am so pleased I did!!!
Aglio Olio conPepperoncino starter and Parma ham, rocket and Regiano pizza main.
Alexander Bottega grappa and perfect ristretto cafe to bring the whole experience together! Well done Marco and team, you get my max rating and continued support!
Ryan
Aug 04, 2016
Zomato
Lesley Street
+4
This place is great, the menu has a good selection of food and drinks. The decor is cute and the vibe is good. My only issue was with the service it wasn't great, to be fair the place was very busy that night, but I think it could have been better.
Jul 31, 2016
Zomato
Natalie Lazaris
+4.5
I think I just found my new favorite itallian restaurant. Owned by two itallians, this place is nothing less than authentic. Wonderful atmosphere, this place is packed with happy and hungry customers. The food is delicious, beautiful flavors and very generous portions. We went to celebrate a birthday and everyone had a great time, especially when the staff sang for the birthday boy. The prawn pasta is something to be reckoned with, it comes flambed -wow!!! Let's not forget their homemade tiramisu, I'd go back everyday for a piece. It's just a homely and memorable experience. You have to book, or else you ain't getting in.
Jul 30, 2016
Zomato
Luz Helena Hanauer
+4
It is managed by real Italians, they make provision if you need gluten free food. Service is great, their tiramisu is perhaps the best in the area, their coffee  holds the Italian name with dignity. Service is average but good enough to have a good night, and most importantly, it is friendly!
The noise can be a bit too loud if there is a full house, but in general it is enjoyable, stylish yet family friendly.
Another thumbs up is the decoration, it is rustic yet sophisticated.
Jun 30, 2016
Zomato
Sarah Druce
+4
I was so excited to come here and I was definitely NOT disappointed - quite possibly the most delicious pizza I've had. I will 100% be back!
Jun 28, 2016
Zomato
Nicci 🌟
+4
I had the best vongela pasta I've ever tasted.. my husband had the fillet pasta which was incredible. Really didn't hear such great reviews.. but I've got to say those people were wrong. The food we ate was really outstanding.
Service wasn't good..the restaurant was full and think thats were the service failed.. we're a table of 10.
Will be back... craving that smokey vongela..
Jun 22, 2016
Zomato
Janice Scheckter
+4
Best coffee in Joburg!!! WE had a great lunch, service spectacular and a very cool setting. I only had an antipasto platter so hard to judge the food prep but everyone at the table enjoyed their meals. On my antipasto platter I would recommend that the mozarella in the caprese is not so bulky in the slicing of it.
Jun 10, 2016
Zomato
My TwoCents
+4.5
We had a wonderful Friday night dinner here and were sat in the corner booth table (which I think is the best seat in the house).  The ambiance is cozy and quaint and equally suitable for an intimate dinner for two or a group of friend.  Food is delicious but what stood out for me was the "Tongue in Green Sauce" starter which is thinly sliced ox tongue, not dissimilar to carpaccio, served with a delicious sauce.  I would highly recommend this, especially as a gentle introduction for anyone who gets queasy at the thought of offal and sweet-meats. I shall be going back to purchase their ground coffee and try their breakfast menu. Keep up the good work!
Jun 09, 2016
Zomato
LactoOvoGastro
+4
Definitely worth a visit if you're one of those people who allow yourself a pizza once in a while and want it to hit the spot! Cooked to perfection on a thin base, lots of choice on toppings and overall great flavor! The wine list didn't disappoint either and the ambience was warm and friendly. Will certainly go back to try the other dishes on the menu, esp the breakfast and coffee. Book ahead if you're a group, this place does get busy on weekends!
Jun 04, 2016
Zomato
Devin Sage
+5
Love this place! Great food, great vibe and really good service. Well above average! All of our orders came out nice and quick. Our waiter knew the menu well. My Caprese Salad was excellent! I will definitely be going back in the near future. Highly recommended!
Jun 04, 2016
Zomato
Tiffany
+4.5
Have been wanting to try this spot for a while now! Was greeted at the front desk by a lovely woman. We didn't have a reservation but she swiftly seated us inside. Me and my boyfriend had a really yummy lunch today. I had beef carpaccio to start, he had the squid heads. Then for mains he had ricotta pasta and I had seafood pasta. The perfect amount of chili and garlic was used in both pastas. So tasty. So fresh. Will definitely be back.
May 30, 2016
Zomato
Tshidi Khunou
+4.5
Awesome Lil place. Hidden away from most places. We decided to have dinner with our friends to catch up on our holiday pics. It's a nice Italian place, down the road from one of my awesome Indian restaurants. It's got those amazing thin crust Pizzas. The pasta was just a perfect portion. It truly is a Gem and I would recommend anyone to try it out. The service was also very good.
May 08, 2016
Zomato
Troye Joseph
+4
Stumbled upon this gem by complete accident one morning whilst in the Parkmore area. Well decorated place with superb food all round. Pasta and pizza selection looks appetizing. Friendly manager who is welcoming and his hands on influence is clear in the restaurants rapport... Excellent choice for an Italian treat
Apr 30, 2016
Zomato
CaraLee
+4
I like this place more and more every time that I eat there. The Eatalian is perfectly on point with it's offering of a solid neighbourhood Italian join that ticks all the boxes. Reasonably priced, absolutely delicious food- check. Lovely setting with homely, cosy decor- check. Amazing wood fired pizzas- check. Good service and an interested owner- check.  Good wine list- check. You can't go wrong with this little place in Parkmore. Highly recommended for a casual dinner or lunch with friends, you won't be disappointed! Tip: order the Farfalle Salmone pasta- it's totally addictive.
Apr 22, 2016
Zomato
Douglas Lorimer
+3.5
Had dinner at the Eatalian last night with the family. Nice setting. Service was reasonable. The did was pretty good. My pizza had a really good thin crust, but was possibly a little oily,although that may have been my fault in my choice. Boglognaise was solid but a little unexciting. Salad was maybe the let down with the pancetta a bit over cooked.
Will definitely give it another go, possibly for breakfast.
Apr 17, 2016
Zomato
Kgahlego Pitsi Boloko-Kewana
+4
Had dinner here last night. Lovely place, great ambiance. I had the chicken Gorgonzola - delish. My date had one of the specials of the day - rabbit. He didn't enjoy it-far too many bones made it difficult to eat, eventually gave up & shared my generous meal with me. Overall, good experience, that rabbit was just a let down.
Apr 14, 2016
Zomato
Tay
+4
Coffee was a bit pungent, but Polenta Burger was amazing !! A beautifully furnished corner cafe with stunning decor and a lovely vibe in Parkmore. I love the location and will certainly be back 🎀
Apr 08, 2016
Zomato
Kubendran Reddy
+4.5
Been looking for a good Italian restaurant and finally tried The Eatalian. A cozy place with a pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff. The pasta was the best I have had in a while and the portions generous. Will definitely go back.
Mar 09, 2016
Zomato
Francois Marais Van Zyl
+4.5
Boasting one of the biggest traditional pizza ovens I have ever seen and the tastiest pizzas with the freshest toppings I have ever tasted.Lovely outlay, décor and atmosphere and conveniently situated out of the hassle and buzzle of the nearby Benmore Gardens Shopping centre.
Mar 07, 2016
Zomato
Nigel Allori
+4
Great little Italian! Nice atmosphere, great service. Well worth the visit. Will definitely revisit. My Pollo Verde a little salty, but really moist, fresh and big portion.
Feb 27, 2016
Zomato
Nasrin Sayed
+4
A delicious night out, from the perfectly balanced beetroot starter, to the oxtail with polenta chips & freshly made basil pesto! Attentive waiters & management - will definitely be back! Looking forward to trying their rabbit.
Feb 25, 2016
Zomato
Liza Richard
+4
Efficient service, nice setup and delicious, flavorsome meals. We tried the fettuccine Salsiccia and it was creamy goodness. I would have preferred the pasta softer and did request this bit it was still rather firm. The Penne Carbonara did have lots of black pepper like the menu states and you may want to request this to be a little toned down if it's not your preference. Nice vibe and I plan on trying out their other menu items 🙂
Feb 19, 2016
Zomato
Michelle
+4
We got takeaway pizza from here so I can't really comment on service etc.. Very well decorated though.
Pizzas were nice enough and would have them again.
We were a bit off put by the reviews on the pastas so feel a bit apprehensive to try them.
We do look forward to spending some good evenings here in future as we live in the area and it is a good local pizza place!
Feb 13, 2016
Zomato
Brent Taylor
+4
Nice atmosphere, good food, friendly staff. Only complaint is music...oldies. Also, the owner was doing bookkeeping/admin with laptop and paperwork out in the restaurant...not very nice.
Feb 06, 2016
Zomato
Alexandra
+3.5
Mm... I have some mixed feelings about the Eatalian.

It's the place to be seen currently with the likes of Vanessa Carreira dining there. The vibe is romantic and trendy.

The service is fast and attentive maybe a little too attentive in that we were constantly be asked if everything was alright - even with our mouths full of food. The tables were a bit squashed which resulted in our waiter bumping us and we also bumped the table behind us when standing to leave. This made for a few uncomfortable apologies.

The pizza and pasta dishes we ordered were incredible and if that's what you are in the mood for then definitely make a booking at the Eatalian. We ordered two none pasta and pizza dishes and they were WAY below par. I cringe thinking of the snotty mushrooms on my dry chicken breast and the un- flambéed alcohol on the meat orders by my father.

My verdict: great pizza and pasta - the starters are also worth a try. For anything else go elsewhere.
Feb 04, 2016
Zomato
DD
+3.5
Needed a much deserved break from the office so gave The Eatalian a try after having bookmarked the restaurant months ago.
Seafood pizza was exactly as it should be, thin crusty base; herby tomato base; and decent amount of seafood. Ordered with extra cheese 😊. My only gripe was that the prawns were still in the shell. But that's laziness for you.
Had to try some antipasti so opted for the crispy squid heads and arancini - risotto, cheese, truffle oil and bolognese crumbed and deep fried. Squid heads were good but needed a sprinkle of salt. Was not impressed with the Arancini though. Needs an injection of flavor and could not taste any truffle. Will give this a miss next time. There will be a next time - heard the pasta is really good. Let's wait and see...
Jan 27, 2016
Zomato
John
+3.5
Pasta and pizza are definitely what is great about this new Restaurant that has sprung up in Parkmore . It has a simple menu and the pasta portions are large and the thin base pizza are excellent , I found the squid heads a little tasteless and the desserts portions were on the small side. Ave per head R180 / R200 .
Jan 24, 2016
Zomato
Irfaan
+4.5
Finally decided to give this place a try and wished I had sooner. Staff and service was great. Pasta cooked to perfection, delicious, flavourful and the pizza straight outa Italy. Definitely one of the better Italian restaurants out there.
Jan 16, 2016
Zomato
Lauras World
+4
Right - Eatalian has been on my radar for over a month and it was time! Eatalian's slogan: "We are all about good food, good coffee & happy people" is simple and genuine. 

Fabio & his brother are not new to the restaurant industry and their 20+ years of experience in several venues including Luigi's (Riverclub), have allowed the Razzino's to perfect good, solid, Italian comfort food (and coffees) in that time. Fabio even roasts his own coffee beans (photos of his coffee roasting machine attached).

Great tasting Italian, comprehensive options, good wine, generous portions and decent pricing. Honestly what is not to love.. I was served well and quickly by Fredo, my waiter. Two components that I really appreciate. 

My one concern would have to be the lack of parking in the area but its still worth the hunt! 

*Recommendation: If you haven't been by, and plan on going by in the evening, just a note that this place is packed Wednesday - Sunday so I would highly recommend booking to avoid disappointment (0113268786).

For more, find me on Twitter: LaurasWorldza
Jan 14, 2016
Zomato
Deidre Akaloo
+4.5
Delicious! Divine food, excellent service and relaxed ambience. Perfect for date night. I enjoyed my dining experience immensely. I would recommend this restaurant
Jan 07, 2016
Zomato
Stacey C
+4
We decided to try the Eatalian after quite some time of having our eyes on it. The waiters were very friendly and accommodating and told us what are the more popular dishes. My husband I decided to try their pastas. The portions were massive but absolutely delicious. I felt that the pasta could have been cooked for 2 more minutes but it could have been the style an authentic Italian place like this had so I was not too critical of that. The owner came to us to check up on our meal and was extremely friendly. We did try a focaccia and it was superb so we are definitely coming back for some pizza. If you are not an Italian fan, they have many other dishes you can order that do not involve pizza or pasta.
Jan 03, 2016
Zomato
Yasmin
+4.5
I LOOOOVED THIS PLACE! Good setting, cute little restaurant that's kept to an Italian concept. Food was amazing! Very tasty and different too. Very good restaurant To go for a date!
Dec 23, 2015
Zomato
Jonty Rosenthal
+3.5
So I waited a few days to write this review

I had heard a lot about the Eatalian, good things.

The vibe and decor is very chilled and relaxed so it seemed we would have a good time

We ordered muscles to share as starters, paprika and cream sauce, my wife loves them and I just wasn't sure about the paprika. It just seemed to give it some bitterness.

My wife had chili and garlic calamari for mains and said there was so much chili that could not eat it.

I had seafood pasta. Firstly to serve pasta with prawns still in the shell grinds me and muscles in the shell. Is this a meal to be eaten with your hands or a fork? Then to take the muscles out the sauce and pasta and arrange them around the edge of the place firstly is very 90s and makes them cold and unappetizing. Pasta was ok, little too much chili and the over cooked prawns and cold muscles didn't make a great combo. I must admit that the calamari in the pasta was perfect.

We then had ice cream which was soft warm and melted basically. Not great.

I cannot count the amount of times a waitron knocked the menu sitting next to me on the table or out table as they walked past.

Not sure I will go again. Would need convincing.
Dec 14, 2015
Zomato
Binita Mistry
+4.5
After our year end work function, 2 of my friends from work and I decided to try out a restaurant in Benmore. We found this cute little place called The Eatalian. The waiters seated us immediately and were very attentive. Our food arrived quickly. My one friend and I shared the Pollo pizza. It was so delicious. My other friend had the springbok carpaccio which he said was really good. Will definitely be going back to The Eatalian to try out the pasta. Great food and great service.
Dec 12, 2015
Zomato
Dipäyän
+4
A great new Italian restaurant in Parkmore. Very nice and cozy ambience. Loved the copper tone. Very friendly and efficient waitstaff. I tried the pizza and it was delicious. Definitely going back to try more.
Dec 12, 2015
Zomato
Lisa Pi
+3.5
I am in LOVE with the decor of this restaurant! What a great setting!
The food was good too.  We had 3 pizza's and 1 pasta dish at the table and not one complaint.  I am on a search to find Jo'burg's best pizza, and what was served at The Eatalian makes them on my top 5 list.  Pizza's are thin and crispy without being soggy or burnt, and the toppings were fair and flavorsome. 
My dad introduced me to this place, and being an Italian chef he often struggles to find food and restaurants he enjoys, so if he likes the food, this place get's my immediate vote!
The owner was very friendly and came by to say hi.  
I look forward to going back to try some of their other dishes.
Dec 08, 2015
Zomato
Angie Bandolini
+4.5
Loved this Italian joint! Italian owner walking around and interacting with all the customers and serving all the food personally giving the restaurant a very homely feel. While the chef in the kitchen (reminded me of the movie CHEF) covered in tattoos with a hardcore look manages to delight the palette with mouth watering dishes. I never go for a creamy pasta but this night I did and it was a solid 9/10. Portions a generous and the decor is stunning luxy industrial inspired! Can't wait to go back 👌🏼
Dec 06, 2015
5
Warren Forster
+5
The food was really delicious and the service was great. If you looking for tasty, flavourful Indian cuisine then this place is a must. I had a masala dosa and the flavours were so good, ill definitely be back. For mains I had a paneer tika masala and it was simply delicious
5
Simone Greeff
+5
I'm in Sandton for a brief work stint and felt like Indian food. Took a chance and popped in here.... and very glad I did. Good service, friendly, made me feel at home (pretty home sick) and well priced.... and the Chicken Tika Masala is just beautiful and fragrant, have not yet had this good in Cape Town. I may just go get the same for "breakfast" tomorrow! Thanks guys!
5
Pam Pam
+5
Delicious food. Poppadums served as appetizers. Food is hot when order hot but yummy. Good service and decent proportions of food served. Quite popular with take away orders.
5
Steven Michael Crowley
+5
Thank you very much for your wonderful bunny chows and masala very professional and yummy 😋
5
RTeeM
+5
Great food, good value, and good service.
4
Banwari Jhawar
+4
Whenever I go to Sandton then at least my 1 meal during the trip is fixed there as it gives proper Indian feel through it's food and taste. My colleagues from different countries also likes Indian cuisine served by them and mainly Rajasthani Masala Bhindi
4
Karlien Delport
+4
Great! Loved it. This is traditional Indian, not Woolies Indian, but I certainly recommend dinner here. Loved the layout of, and variety in the menu. Loved everything we ordered. Absolutely loved the leftovers we took home and had for lunch the next day. Loved who the chef goes out of his way to turn savoury dishes into desert. The staff were friendly. Love the gluten free items l could order and enjoy. The only thing I didn't love was the very, very, uncharacteristically small portion of traditional Indian ice-cream I was sent home with. We took cold dessert to eat at home and I was super disappointed. So 1 out of 11 was not to be loved. 4.5 out of 5 rating. 10 out of 10 will return. They have a generator so you can eat there when loadshedding is preventing you from cooking at home.
4
Steve Chiaberta
+4
My wife and I absolutely love this restaurant. The decor and ambiance are great, but it's the food that is truly special. We have tried various dishes now and we both think it is the best Indian food we've ever had! The portions are good and the prices are reasonable - the only over-priced item is the wine by the glass (ridiculously so), but then their corkage is fair. The person who gave a bad review must have caught them on a rare bad day, because we have nothing but praise for this restaurant.
5
Ashok Deivasigamani
+5
The best biriyani that you can get in Johannesburg is in this restaurant.
5
Candz Kaal
+5
We ordered the chicken korma, butter chicken and lamb jogan rosh. All curries were super tasty and the lamb was the most tender lamb I've had in a curry in a very long while. Definitely worth 5 stars! PS the cheesy Naan is an absolute must. 😍👌
5
Vana Naidoo
+5
Amazing Indian food 🙌🏾 Great value for money 👍🏾 Terrific vegetarian curries 🫶🏾
4
kevin pillay
+4
I had the fish curry with butter naan.... 😋